Showing posts with label foreclosure. Show all posts
Showing posts with label foreclosure. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Housing Disaster 2.0

If you thought the housing debacle was bad, wait till you see what 2.0 has in store!

The intransigence of Wall st to help homeowners resolve their problems is now coming back to bite them, HARD!

The mortgage backed securities that are the touchstone of the Trillion dollar securitization scam are mainly worthless, despite the industry's obfuscation. The reason is that most of the mortgages underlying the securities are underwater, worth less than the housing backing them up.

No one is willing to acknowledge this devastating fact. But remember the real estate boom? Property values were rising at 10-20% annually, but all the while, home equity was actually falling. Historically, the average home had 50% equity, but during the boom, because of the low-no down payment purchases and the cash out refi frenzy, the average home had only 25% equity by the peak of the boom in 2005-6.

Up to now, home prices have fallen 25-30%, with no end in sight, which means that the average home at this point has negative equity!

Home prices will continue to fall for the foreseeable future because of the humongous number of homes in the foreclosure pipeline. Unemployment is now driving even good credit, 30 year fixed mortgage holders to default on their mortgage payments. Experience has shown that anyone who is 3 months or more behind in their mortgage payments, will never catch up and will become a foreclosure statistic.

To that number you have to add a substantial number of people who are current on their payments, but are significantly underwater. If you paid $425,000 for your home 4 years ago, with 10% down, meaning you have a $383,500 mortgage, but the value of your home is now only $295,000, you, like many similarly situated homeowners, will seriously consider walking away, or "Strategically Default" on your mortgage. Others would not consider it on moral grounds.

Think about it. Could you buy a similar home or even a better one for the same or smaller mortgage payment? How much would it cost to rent a similar or better home? Do you really want to throw good money, your retirement, your child's educational account, into a home that may not recover its value for years and years?

As of this writing, up to 40% of foreclosure sales are the result of home owners walking away from their mortgages.

Finally, the pool of potential home buyers shrinks by the day. Unemployed people are automatically excluded from the ranks of home buyers. More and more people's credit scores are dropping because of financial hardship, while at the same time banks are demanding higher and higher credit scores, with 750-780 not uncommon. Another thing the banks are demanding are bigger down payments, with many demanding 20% down, which with total acquisition costs bring the required cash to buy a house up to 25% or more. Not many first time buyers have that and trade up buyers are few because either they cannot sell their homes because they are under water or their credit has been dinged because of missed mortgage payments.

And, of course just over the horizon are higher interest rates as the Fed QE2's inflationary impact spreads from stocks and commodities to the broader economy. Higher mortgage interest rates will be just another nail in the housing market's coffin.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Obama Blinked!

Although the so called Bankruptcy Cramdown provision; the ability of BK judges to reduce the amount of loans on property in the course of the BK, is extended for the first time to first mortgages on principal residences; the fact that there is no general across the board principal reduction for home owners will keep the bill from solving the housing crisis.

Giving "Incentives" to unscrupulous lenders to cooperate and lower mortgage payments will not work. It hasn't worked in Hope or Hope for homeowner plans as we have seen.

There are simply too many considerations and limitations; who owns the mortgage or part of the mortgage? Who is servicing it? Do you know that some well known mortgage services eagerly purchase defaulting loans and make huge profits by adding fees and foreclosing on them? What are the mortgage owners or their investors contractual obligations toward modification or principal reduction, etc.

Only a Federal Law could cut through those considerations and force action by the lenders.

I believe Obama knows the answer is principal reductions on home mortgages down to 80-90% of CURRENT market value is the most powerful answer to the foreclosure crisis.

This would allow the 20% or so of all mortgage holders who are underwater, whose mortgage is more than the house is worth, to reset to payments they can afford. If these people are not relieved, they have ZERO incentive to sacrifice their life savings or retirement savings to keep paying their mortgage.

Perhaps in a few months Obama can say, we tried everything else and it did not work, so we are now going to force lenders to reduce principal on all loans to affordable levels. He probably felt it would be too radical and face too much opposition from the Know-Nothings, like Eric Cantor; and getting something passed now was better than getting nothing passed.

However, the hour is late, perhaps too late to put the housing monster back in its cage. It is already sucking up the scarce money homeowners need to service not only their mortgage but their credit cards, auto and student loans, which will cause massive defaults in those areas, hurting the banks even more.

There is even more carnage just over the horizon as I point out in an earlier posting.

There is already baked-in to the forecasts by Credit Suisse about 6 Million more foreclosure over the coming two years because of massive, Trillion dollar defaults in Alt-A and Option Arm loans.

Already 60% of Option Arms are underwater and more than 80% of borrowers are paying less than the interest owed on each payment, thereby Increasing the amount of principal owed with every payment!

Also, something I have not seen discussed is that even Prime loan defaults will probably skyrocket in the next 2-3 years. Historically their defaults peak 3-5 years after they are issued.

That means that the Trillions of dollars in prime loans written at the peak of the boom, 2005 and 2006 and therefore have suffered the sharpest home value drops,will enter peak default periods in 2008-2011. Already, Prime loans are entering default stage at a higher rate than sub prime in some areas!

Finally, the Know Nothings are crazy if they feel that an overall mortgage default rate of 10% is acceptable!

This is fully 10 Times the normal mortgage default rate! Many banks have about 50% of their capital in residential mortgages. A 10% default rate on their assets would reduce their lending capacity by 10-20x that amount. Such a blow to their lending and therefore earning ability would cripple them.

The Know Nothings are now, predictably, so consumed with the fear (they love to spread fear, remember the Yellow and Orange Alerts during the 2004 campaign?) that a homeowner who cheats, obviously a minority of all borrowers gets bailed out?

What about the banks and Wall St where All of the big banks and brokerage houses, rating agencies and others who created this mess in the first place? Aren't they being bailed out regardless? Oh, I forgot, the banks are too big to fail, but the homeowner is too small to bail.

In summation, I believe Obama's Home Rescue Plan is too little, too late, especially after the Know Nothings get finished savaging it. Will he get a second chance to make it better? Will it matter?

Saturday, February 14, 2009

"Bank opposition to helping homeowners, Senator Durbin says, "was (is) very shortsighted in light of the mess they have created in our economy."

Banks Are Not Serious About Helping to Keep People in Their Homes!

You have heard that "banks want you to be able to pay your mortgage, they don't want your house." I have even said that in the past. While true on an individual level, today, bankers are taking a short term view to first to protect themselves, (and their jobs) then deal with the devil later on.

Look at These Excerpts from Yahoo News, Friday, Feb 13, 2009

The (housing) industry strategy all along has been to buy time and thwart regulation, financial-services lobbyists tell BusinessWeek . "We were like the Dutch boy with his finger in the dike," says one business advocate who, like several colleagues, insists on anonymity, fearing career damage. Some admit that, in retrospect, their clients, which include Bank of America (NYSE:BAC - News), Citigroup (NYSE:C - News), and JPMorgan Chase (NYSE:JPM - News), would have been better off had they agreed two years ago to address foreclosures systematically rather than pin their hopes on an unlikely housing rebound.

A major reason financial institutions and investors are so determined to avoid modifying loan terms more aggressively has to do with accounting nuances, say industry lobbyists. If, for example, a bank lowered the balance of a certain mortgage, there would be a strong argument that it would have to reduce the value on its balance sheet of all similar mortgages in the same geographic area to reflect the danger that the region had hit an economic slump. Under this stringent approach, financial industry mortgage-related losses could far surpass even the grim $1.1 trillion estimated by Goldman Sachs (NYSE:GS - News) in January. A desire to postpone this devastating situation helps explain lenders' intransigence, says Rick Sharga, vice-president of marketing at RealtyTrac, an Irvine (Calif.) firm that analyzes foreclosure patterns.


What About the Plans Already Announced to Help Homeowners?

Hope Now Alliance, a government-endorsed private sector organization announced by Paulson on Oct. 10, 2007. Lenders promised to cooperate with nonprofit credit counselors who would help borrowers prevent defaults. Faith Schwartz, a former subprime mortgage executive, was put in charge.

An analysis White did of a sample of 21,219 largely subprime mortgages modified in November under Hope Now in 2008 found that only 35% of the cases resulted in lower payments. In 18%, payments stayed the same; in the remaining 47%, they rose. The reason for this strange result: Lenders and loan servicers are tacking on missed payments, taxes, and big fees to borrowers' monthly bills.

Then there was Hope for Homeowners. It was already anticipated that its fine print would discourage all but a few borrowers. "We knew it was likely to have limited appeal," says Preston, the former secretary of HUD, which oversees the FHA. George Miller, executive director of the American Securitization Forum, a Wall Street trade group, calls the program and its 25 refinanced loans "useless" because of the onerous details.

The banks clearly are looking out for themselves first and foremost. As one banker put it, "Banks are too big to fail and homeowners are too small to bail!"

So, that is their attitude. They foisted fraudulent financial products onto homeowners and are now refusing to take responsibility and help their victims.

Here is a Typical Story of Homeowners Hoodwinked by the Banks!

Stefanie and James Smith of Santa Clarita, Calif., fear they may need the help of a bankruptcy court if they are to keep the subdivision home they bought for $579,000 in November 2005. Stefanie, 37, a university human resources coordinator, and James, 40, a federal law enforcement agent, borrowed the entire amount in two subprime loans that required a total monthly payment of $3,000. A representative of their lender, Countrywide, told them not to worry, says Stefanie: They would be able to refinance in a year.

By mid-2007 they were running late on payments, and refinancing options had dried up. With their monthly bill scheduled to jump to more than $4,000 this January due to a rising mortgage rate, Stefanie contacted Countrywide last summer. She asked for a loan modification so they could avoid default. In December the lender said it would be willing to increase their payment by $600. That was better than the scheduled rise of $1,100, so the Smiths agreed.

But now they are struggling to pay the higher amount. Countrywide's parent, BofA, declined to comment, citing the Smiths' privacy. After BusinessWeek's questions, though, Countrywide called them to discuss cutting their payments.

"We knew when we bought that the payments would be a stretch," says Stefanie. She regrets assuming they would be able to refinance at a lower rate. "We are not deadbeats," she adds. "All we want is a mortgage we can afford."

Our Advice to Homeowners Facing Foreclosure!

If you are now losing your home because you cannot pay your mortgage, don't rape your 401(k) or your children's college fund, you will Never be able to replace those funds in the economy we are entering.

Accept the possibility that you have already lost your house, you did sign the mortgage, probably without being represented by a lawyer, that is your responsibilty.

Now, you can either be put out of the house with No money left to your name, a bad thing, having raided your savings, retirement and children's funds, or you can stop paying now and be put out later with your savings intact to finance a new start, a better outcome.

With more and more people underwater, making payments on homes worth less than their mortgage, this will become a popular tactic and will eventually force the banks to help.

In fact, we are seeing an increasing number of people who stop making their payments and challenge the banks in court. If the bank cannot produce your original mortgage and note, they cannot proceed with the foreclosure! It is estimated that fully 40% of banks cannot produce this documentation, so it is well worth the risk.

Contact me directly if you would like more information on this subject or assitance in implementing it. I can be reached at 646-961-3818

Oh, what about the Moral Hazzard such a brazzen act of self help would produce? I think the danger of producing Moron Hazzards are much greater; people exhausting their money to make payments on homes that are underwater!

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Latest Housing News

Foreclosures were up 81% in 2008 compared to 2007. There were over 3 Million foreclosures filed and over 861,000 people actually lost their homes. This number probably would have topped 1 million were it not for various foreclosure moratoria passed by several states. All they do is prolong the agony for most. Although some experts are calling for a bottom in 2010, at about a 33% drop in housing prices, there is no rational reason to believe this estimate. I think they say that because 2010 is a year away and probably no one will remember they said that at that time. To the contrary, the only bright spot in real estate has been the low interest rates and that bright spot will be extinquished by the end of this year with the bursting of the Treasury Bond Bubble.

The drying up of funds for real estate lending combined with new lending regulations that eliminate half of the people who could borrow before, in addition to the layoffs and the growing number of people "sending the keys to the bank" because they are under water, will combine to drive housing prices lower than anyone dared project, I believe.

Thinking of buying real estate? Put the money you were planning to use for the purchase (30% down required!), into silver. The overall economy is in a deflation now, with the prices of everything going down, including gold and silver. However, when the economy turns, inflation will be back with a vengeance. This situation is analagous to 1971 when the average home sold for $20,000. Let's see what would happen if Mary bought a home for $20,000 and John put $20,000 in silver. The economy was bad for several years in the 70'S but when the economy turned, prices shot up. Mary's home jumped to $40,000 in 1980, but John's $20,000 investment in silver was worth over $770,000 in 1980!

The stage is set for a repeat performance. When the economy turns, real estate appreciation will be hampered by the huge inventory of unsold homes, restrictive lending standards that will eliminate half of the usual buyers, and sky high interest rates. Silver will have no such retardants holding it back. As it is, silver is more scarce now than in 1980, since 95% of all silver mined is consumed by industrial uses. Also, Warren Buffet has recently bought 20% of All the silver in the World! Think he knows something that we don't?

Friday, December 26, 2008

Bailout This!

Bailout This!
I advise my personal finance sclients who have mortgages that they cannot pay, especially if they owe more than the house is worth, to stop paying their mortgages!

Sounds kind of radical, you say.

But when you understand what the financial system has done to these homeowners you may understand.

It is simply a matter of self defense, financial self defense.

The Wall St syndicates; banks, investment houses, bond insurers, bond rating agencies etc. conspired in true racketeering style, to produce fraudulent financial instruments and then foisted them onto unsophisticated borrowers.

Uncomfortable with the word, fraud? Fraud is a "deception made for personal gain," according to the dictionary.

Rating bonds backed by sub prime mortgages as investment grade, AAA, in order to collect fees, are a prime example.

Issuing insurance; credit default swaps, with no assets to back them up, in order to collect fees, is another example.

Knowingly falsifying data on mortgage applications, in order to collect fees is yet another example.

Without these key fraudulent practices by the mortgage and financial industry, the entire sub prime debacle could never have happened.

Now that the mortgage mess has "inextricably" blown up in the faces of the banks, essentially putting them out of business; they are demanding that home owners whom they have defrauded, continue to honor their commitment to pay their toxic mortgages and to now to bail them out with trillions of taxpayer dollars.

As one Wall St Bigwig said, "The banks are too big to fail and the homeowner is too small to bail."

So the battle lines are drawn. The banks on one side, want to drain your very life blood in order to keep you paying their mortgages, all the while robbing your children and grand children by blackmailing us and getting Trillions of our dollars to repay their losses so they can stay afloat.

These massive loans and cash infusions will produce huge deficits that will be passed onto future generations.

Unfortunately, there is no bailout for the home owner, only half-hearted measures like loan modifications that do not solve the borrower's problems.

Look at the widely touted Hope for Homeowners rescue plan. It was projected to save 400,000 homeowners from foreclosure. Only 312 loans were modified. And we now know that over half of all borrowers who have had their mortgages modified have become delinquent again in less than 6 months.

Modifications are not the answer. Slashing the balance of the outstanding loans to 80% of the current market value of the property, like they did in the First Great Depression is a far more effective remedy as it sets up a payment level that the borrower can afford.

Therefore, in the absence of any willingness on the part of banks or government to bail them out, borrowers are left to defend themselves against the unscrupulous banks. It is really a case of financial self defense. You know where the banks are coming from, it is up to you to fight them.

It is enough that most of these troubled borrowers, especially the 15 million or so who are "Underwater," who owe more than their house is worth, will lose their homes one way or the other.

That is their punishment for taking out a loan without having the advice of a financial professional or being represented at closing by their own lawyer; not the mortgage broker's or real estate broker's lawyer, at the closing.

But it should not mean that they have to ravish their life savings, retirement accounts or their children's inheritance to placate the bloodthirsty banks.

As an experienced real estate investor, former bank loan officer and Personal Financial Coach providing assisting troubled home owners, I have many people in this situation.

My advice to them is to stop paying their mortgage, do not give the banks one more cent of their hard earned money.

We then show them how to remain in their homes for up to two years or so without paying a penny to the banks so that they can accumulate some money to get a fresh start. In some cases, the banks pay my clients thousands of dollars to leave the premises.

What about the eventual foreclosure? Won't it hurt their credit?

Yes it will, but they would be in the same situation credit wise when they eventually lost their homes.

Their choice is to be evicted from their home penniless, after going through their life savings or with the savings intact and a few dollars to move on with.

Also, when the dust settles, they will be able to buy a house for less than half of what they paid for the one they lost, according to knowledgeable experts.

If the banks and their proxies in government will not bail out the home owner, he must bail himself out, period.

Copyright 2008 Bill Young. Bill is a Personal Financial Coach. You can sign up for a free, year long course with Bill in How to Solve Your Money Problems here: http://HowtoSolveYourMoneyProblems.Com